Prime Crime: Hairstylist’s Bloody Scissors Expose Gruesome Murder

The podcast details the investigation into the disappearance and murder of Jolene Cummings, a Florida hairstylist. The prime suspect, Jennifer Cybert, was discovered to be a fugitive named Kimberly Kesler with a history of assumed identities and violence. After a complex trial, Kesler was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison, but the victim's body was never recovered.

Jolene's Disappearance

• 00:01:26 Jolene Cummings, a Florida mother and hairstylist, went missing in May 2018, not showing up to meet her soon-to-be ex-husband to exchange their children. Her mother, Anne, reported her missing after becoming concerned about Jolene's unusual absence and lack of communication. The disappearance immediately caused concern within the community and sparked a large-scale investigation by the Nassau County Sheriff's Office.

Initial Suspect & Investigation

• 00:04:18 The investigation initially focused on Jolene's ex-husband, Jason Cummings, and her boyfriend, Jason G., as potential suspects, due to their close relationships with her. Law enforcement interviewed both individuals, and while Jason Cummings was ruled out, Jason G. became a person of interest due to a previous domestic dispute and his evasive behavior. The detectives also investigated Jolene's social circle and looked into potential drug use.

Jennifer Cybert/Kimberly Kesler

• 00:17:18 The investigation took a significant turn with the emergence of Jennifer Cybert, Jolene's co-worker, as a key figure. It was later revealed that Jennifer was actually Kimberly Kesler, a fugitive wanted by the FBI for over 25 years. Kimberly was using a stolen identity and had a history of violence and unstable behavior, which included changing identities and aliases.

Evidence & Arrest

• 00:25:32 Numerous pieces of evidence linked Kimberly Kesler to Jolene's murder, including a gas station purchase, blood on her shoes, and Walmart purchases of cleaning supplies and a large carving knife. The police searched the salon where Jolene worked and found a significant amount of blood, indicating a violent crime. Ultimately, Kimberly was arrested and charged with first-degree murder.

Trial & Conviction

• 00:35:31 Kimberly Kesler's trial was complex and challenging due to her erratic behavior, including a hunger strike and disruptive outbursts. The defense attempted to portray Jolene as a person with a drug problem and suggest self-defense as a motive for the altercation. However, the state presented significant evidence of premeditation and a violent crime. Ultimately, the jury found Kimberly Kesler guilty of first-degree murder and grand theft auto, sentencing her to life in prison without parole.